Jump to Section
MASSACHUSETTS ST DEV FIN AGY REV
CUSIP: 57584YQK8
By &Evergreen Team•Updated: Nov 18, 2025
BBB-Cautious
Overview
Overview
•Bond Name/Type: Massachusetts Development Finance Agency Revenue Bonds (Tufts Medicine / Wellforce Obligated Group, CUSIP 57584YQK8)
•Top-Line Classification: Cautious (medium confidence)
•Synopsis: FY 2024 CHIA filings show a –9.1 % operating margin, –0.94× DSCR and only 19.6 days-cash for the Obligated Group while long-term-debt equals roughly the mid-80s percent of capitalization (Signals 32, 31, 30, 23). Although YTD 6/30/25 losses have narrowed (–2.2 % margin), the Group is still burning equity in aggregate ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Hospital Financial Performance 2024 Databook; 2024-01-01)) and remains exposed to the 1.0× annual DSCR floor within the next 12 months, with the 2027 8.5 % bridge issue ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025; 2025-11-12)) sitting as a hard refinancing wall.
Signal 31
Net cash used in operating activities (203,858)
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Hospital Financial Performance 2024 Databook • 2024-01-01
Signal 28
MDFA Series E Bonds (Tufts Medicine Obligated Group) Due 2027 8.5 150,000
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025 • 2025-11-12
Rationale
Rationale
Wellforce experienced a severe financial crisis in FY 2022, posting a $250 million operating loss and –$204 million operating cash burn that drove system-wide days-cash from a historical 75+ days down to roughly 40 and forced total debt to about $992 million at 95 % of capitalization (Signals 32, 31, 30, 23, 29). In October 2024, constrained market access compelled the Obligated Group to issue a $150 million tax-exempt bridge at 8.5 % due October 2027—a rate signaling acute distress—to stabilize liquidity and fund ongoing operations ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025; 2025-11-12)). By FY 2024 (fiscal year ended Sept 30, 2024), losses had narrowed but the system remained in distress with a –9.1 % operating margin, –0.94× DSCR, and only 19.6 days-cash, effectively consistent with the covenant danger zone flagged in the master-indenture DSCR and days-cash tests (Signals 24, 30). The FY 2024 and YTD 6/30/25 improvements documented below represent a partial recovery from that crisis, but the Group remains sub-covenant on an economic basis, with continued equity erosion and a large bullet maturity within roughly 18–24 months (Signals 31, 23, 28).
Signal 28
MDFA Series E Bonds (Tufts Medicine Obligated Group) Due 2027 8.5 150,000
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025 • 2025-11-12
Baseline from Foundation Analysis
•Structure: gross-receivables pledge; no rate-setting authority—operating risk stays with the Obligated Group.
•Covenant: minimum 1.0× DSCR is a performance floor under the Master Indenture.
•Historic cushion: >2.0× DSCR and >75 days cash, frequently supported by investment gains.
•Primary risks: margin volatility, thin liquidity versus fixed charges, above-market leverage.
Assessment of New Evidence (signals ordered by weight)
Liquidity & Cash Burn (Revenue | Liquidity)
•System days-cash effectively collapsed into the teens from the historic 75-day norm ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Hospital Financial Performance 2024 Databook; 2024-01-01)), with FY 2024 CHIA filings confirming ~19.6 days-cash and June-24 interim data showing an even lower intra-year point ((Wellforce Obligated Group FY2024 UGG Financials; 2024-09-30)).
Signal 31
Net cash used in operating activities (203,858)
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Hospital Financial Performance 2024 Databook • 2024-01-01
Signal 30
Tufts Medicine Inc. Days Cash On Hand Tufts Medicine Obligated Group as of September 30, 2024 Total
Wellforce Obligated Group FY2024 UGG Financials • 2024-09-30
•Unrestricted net assets continued to decline through 6/30/25, evidencing that the modest margin recovery has not yet translated to sustained cash generation and that the Obligated Group is still structurally cash-negative on a trailing basis ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Hospital Financial Performance 2024 Databook; 2024-01-01)). No structural mitigants exist under the gross-revenues pledge: any further operating slippage flows directly into covenant stress.
Signal 31
Net cash used in operating activities (203,858)
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Hospital Financial Performance 2024 Databook • 2024-01-01
Leverage (Debt/Leverage)
•Debt-to-capitalization remains very high—mid-80s to mid-90s percent range depending on measure ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Databook Data Through June 30 2024; 2024-06-30))—materially above the ~60 % peer norm cited in the foundation and magnifying fixed-charge pressure as liquidity shrinks. The 8.5 % bridge financing, layered on top of existing long-term debt, keeps consolidated leverage elevated and compresses the margin for error ahead of the 2027 bullet (Signals 23, 29, 28).
Signal 23
Total Debt Outstanding $992,005 ... Long-Term Indebtedness to Capitalization 95%
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Databook Data Through June 30 2024 • 2024-06-30
Hospital-Level Traction but Uneven (Operations/Collections)
•Flagship Tufts MC rebounded from 2 days-cash and 0.65× DSCR at 6/30/24 ((Wellforce Obligated Group FY2024 UGG Financials; 2024-09-30)) to 20.7 days-cash and 1.36× DSCR at FY-end ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Report Through 12 31 2024; 2025-11-12)) and now posts a 2.3 % YTD margin with a $213 million equity gain ().
Signal 30
Tufts Medicine Inc. Days Cash On Hand Tufts Medicine Obligated Group as of September 30, 2024 Total
Wellforce Obligated Group FY2024 UGG Financials • 2024-09-30
Signal 6
FY 2024 Tufts MC: Days Cash 20.7; DSCR 1.36×; Op margin –1.54
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Report Through 12 31 2024 • 2025-11-12
Signal 8
YTD 6/30/25 Tufts MC margin ≈ 2.29 %; UNA + $213 M
•Lowell General shows a similar upswing—YTD 6.0 % margin and $10 million equity add ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025; 2025-11-12))—but retains only 9 days-cash ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Annual Report Databook 2025; 2025-01-01)).
Signal 10
Lowell YTD 6/30/25 margin ≈ 6.04 %; UNA + $10.4 M
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025 • 2025-11-12
Signal 9
Lowell FY 2024: Days Cash 8.81; DSCR 0.94×; Op margin –3.54 %
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Annual Report Databook 2025 • 2025-01-01
•Melrose-Wakefield remains liquidity-constrained (1.9 days-cash, 0.27× DSCR, (Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Annual Report Databook 2024; 2024-01-01)) despite edging into positive territory YTD 2025 ((Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025; 2025-11-12)).
Signal 11
Melrose FY 2024: Days Cash 1.86; DSCR 0.27×; Op margin –8.04 %
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Annual Report Databook 2024 • 2024-01-01
Signal 12
Melrose YTD 6/30/25 margin ≈ 0.79 %; UNA + $11.9 M
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025 • 2025-11-12
•These improvements help, yet under a consolidated gross-receivables pledge the weakest link (Melrose-Wakefield) still drags on consolidated coverage and keeps economic DSCR near the 1.0× floor.
Red Flags
•Days-cash in the teens to low-20s across the Obligated Group (Signals 30, 27).
•Consolidated DSCR negative or near-zero on an economic basis in FY 2024 and still thin on a trailing basis despite hospital-level gains (Signals 32, 31).
•Leverage entrenched at the mid-80s to mid-90s percent of capitalization (Signals 23, 29).
Given that all three red flags hit foundation-identified primary risks and are not cushioned by structural protections, the Cautious classification remains appropriate.
Signals & Trends
3. Signals & Expanded Implications
(Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025; 2025-11-12): MDFA Series E Bonds (Tufts Medicine Obligated Group) Due 2027 8.5 150,000 [Offering Memorandum; 2024-10-15; p.1]
Signal 28
MDFA Series E Bonds (Tufts Medicine Obligated Group) Due 2027 8.5 150,000
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025 • 2025-11-12
– Adds high-cost, short-maturity debt; raises fixed charges and refinancing risk within roughly 24 months. Departure from the prior, more laddered debt plan and a clear marker of constrained market access.
(Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Hospital Financial Performance 2024 Databook; 2024-01-01): “Net cash used in operating activities (203,858)” [FY 2024 Audit; 2024-12-15; p.45; CFO]
Signal 31
Net cash used in operating activities (203,858)
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Hospital Financial Performance 2024 Databook • 2024-01-01
– Confirms material cash burn at the consolidated level; directly compresses unrestricted liquidity and corroborates the CHIA-reported equity erosion trend. Negative change versus prior periods of neutral to modestly positive operating cash flow.
(Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022; 2022-09-30): “LOSS FROM OPERATIONS (250,720)” [FY 2024 Audit; 2024-12-15; p.3; CFO]
Signal 32
LOSS FROM OPERATIONS (250,720)
Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022 • 2022-09-30
– Core margin deterioration that triggered the FY 2022 crisis; underpins the high-leverage, low-liquidity starting point for the current turnaround and explains the system’s exposure to any renewed operating volatility.
(Wellforce Obligated Group FY2024 UGG Financials; 2024-09-30): “Tufts Medicine Inc. Days Cash On Hand Tufts Medicine Obligated Group as of September 30, 2024 Total … 40” [Management Certificate; 2024-12-15; Exh. B]
Signal 30
Tufts Medicine Inc. Days Cash On Hand Tufts Medicine Obligated Group as of September 30, 2024 Total
Wellforce Obligated Group FY2024 UGG Financials • 2024-09-30
– Official covenant-calculated days-cash metric showing a dramatic decline from the historical 75-day range; combined with CHIA’s ~19.6-day figure, this underscores both the deterioration and the sensitivity of the credit to even small additional draws.
(Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Databook Data Through June 30 2024; 2024-06-30): “Total Debt Outstanding $992,005 … Long-Term Indebtedness to Capitalization 95%” [FY 2024 Audit; 2024-12-15; p.28]
Signal 23
Total Debt Outstanding $992,005 ... Long-Term Indebtedness to Capitalization 95%
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Databook Data Through June 30 2024 • 2024-06-30
– Confirms a highly leveraged balance sheet; leverage far above peer norms and a key driver of the fragile DSCR profile.
(Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022; 2022-09-30): “Long-term debt—net of current portion 915,025 805,552” [FY 2024 Audit; 2024-12-15; p.28]
Signal 29
Long-term debt—net of current portion 915,025 805,552
Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022 • 2022-09-30
– Year-over-year increase in long-term debt of more than $100 million; indicates that the system relied on incremental borrowing rather than internally generated funds to navigate the crisis, raising forward fixed-charge risk.
(Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022; 2022-09-30): “Days cash on hand 52.8 77.1” [System Dashboard; 2024-11-30; slide 4]
Signal 27
Days cash on hand 52.8 77.1
Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022 • 2022-09-30
– Internal system slide documenting the long-term erosion of liquidity from a prior 75+-day level; when juxtaposed with the 40-day covenant figure and CHIA’s ~19.6-day datapoint, it demonstrates a structurally weaker liquidity regime.
(Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022; 2022-09-30): “Debt Service Coverage Ratio … 2.2” [Master Indenture Certificate; 2024-12-20; p.2; Treasurer]
Signal 24
The Debt Service Coverage Ratio for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2024, calculated as of the e
Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022 • 2022-09-30
– Shows that coverage remains technically compliant under the Master Indenture calculation, but the gap between covenant DSCR and economic DSCR (after adjusting for hospital-level performance) is narrowing.
(Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022; 2022-09-30): “No Member of the Obligated Group is in default” [Master Indenture Certificate; 2024-12-20; p.3; Treasurer]
Signal 25
To the best of my knowledge, no Member of the Obligated Group is in default in the performance of an
Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022 • 2022-09-30
– Confirms legal compliance; offsets outright default-risk perception but does not mitigate the underlying liquidity and leverage risks.
(Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022; 2022-09-30): “In our opinion … present fairly” [Deloitte Audit Opinion; 2024-12-15; p.1; Partner]
Signal 26
We have audited the consolidated financial statements ... In our opinion, the accompanying financial
Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022 • 2022-09-30
– High-quality financial reporting supports the reliability of the disclosed metrics and the integrity of the covenant testing framework.
(Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2023; 2023-09-30): “Income (loss) from operations 23,190 23,959” [FY 2024 Audit; 2024-12-15; quarterly detail]
Signal 22
Income (loss) from operations 23,190 23,959
Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2023 • 2023-09-30
– Q4 positive operating income that illustrates the early stages of margin recovery; important for trajectory analysis but small relative to the cumulative deficit.
(Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022; 2022-09-30): “(DEFICIENCY) EXCESS OF REVENUE OVER EXPENSES (214,024)” [FY 2024 Audit; 2024-12-15; p.3]
Signal 33
(DEFICIENCY) EXCESS OF REVENUE OVER EXPENSES (214,024)
Wellforce Obligated Group Financial Statements 2022 • 2022-09-30
– Total deficit measure that captures both operating and non-operating performance; reinforces the story of equity erosion despite some non-operating offsets.
(Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Report Through 12 31 2024; 2025-11-12): “FY 2024 Tufts MC: Days Cash 20.7; DSCR 1.36×; Op margin –1.54” [CHIA / Hospital Report]
Signal 6
FY 2024 Tufts MC: Days Cash 20.7; DSCR 1.36×; Op margin –1.54
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Report Through 12 31 2024 • 2025-11-12
– Shows a sharp hospital-level rebound from extreme liquidity stress; signals that the flagship entity is stabilizing faster than the consolidated group and may eventually pull consolidated ratios upward.
Signal 8
YTD 6/30/25 Tufts MC margin ≈ 2.29 %; UNA + $213 M
– Early signs that the flagship hospital is generating positive economic value; supports the thesis that system-level recovery could be anchored by Tufts MC’s improving profitability and rebuilding equity base.
(Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025; 2025-11-12): “Lowell YTD 6/30/25 margin ≈ 6.04 %; UNA + $10.4 M” [YTD Lowell Report]
Signal 10
Lowell YTD 6/30/25 margin ≈ 6.04 %; UNA + $10.4 M
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025 • 2025-11-12
– Indicates strong operating traction at Lowell; while liquidity remains thin, the magnitude of improvement reduces downward pressure on consolidated DSCR.
(Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Annual Report Databook 2025; 2025-01-01): “Lowell FY 2024: Days Cash 8.81; DSCR 0.94×; Op margin –3.54 %” [CHIA Lowell Report]
Signal 9
Lowell FY 2024: Days Cash 8.81; DSCR 0.94×; Op margin –3.54 %
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Annual Report Databook 2025 • 2025-01-01
– Demonstrates how fragile Lowell’s liquidity position was entering FY 2025; underscores system exposure from a weaker subsidiary despite later improvements.
(Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Annual Report Databook 2024; 2024-01-01): “Melrose FY 2024: Days Cash 1.86; DSCR 0.27×; Op margin –8.04 %” [CHIA Melrose Report]
Signal 11
Melrose FY 2024: Days Cash 1.86; DSCR 0.27×; Op margin –8.04 %
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis Annual Report Databook 2024 • 2024-01-01
– Confirms Melrose-Wakefield as the deepest structural weakness in the Obligated Group, with liquidity so low that it materially drags consolidated ratios even when other hospitals improve.
(Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025; 2025-11-12): “Melrose YTD 6/30/25 margin ≈ 0.79 %; UNA + $11.9 M” [YTD Melrose Report]
Signal 12
Melrose YTD 6/30/25 margin ≈ 0.79 %; UNA + $11.9 M
Massachusetts Center for Health Information and Analysis (CHIA) YTD Financial Data Through 6 30 2025 • 2025-11-12
– Shows early but fragile momentum at Melrose; positive margins reduce immediate downside risk, but the liquidity base remains too thin to materially change the consolidated credit profile.
Outlook
4. Outlook (12-month qualitative view)
Base Path: Modest operating gains continue but remain sub-breakeven, leaving DSCR near the 1.0× floor and days-cash hovering in the 20-30 range. Management’s FY 2025 budget and any external liquidity moves (summer 2025 board cycle) will be decisive.
Downside Scenario: If YTD improvements stall and net cash burn persists at FY 2024 levels, days-cash could slide below 15 and trigger a springing consultant or waiver request ahead of the next annual DSCR test (Signals 31, 32, 30).
Upside Scenario: Consolidated breakeven operations plus a material liquidity injection—through philanthropy, asset monetization or a system-wide cost reset—could rebuild days-cash above 45 and restore a 1.3×–1.5× DSCR, opening a path back to Stable.
Near-Term Catalysts
•FY 2025 Q2 results (April 2025) – first full quarter post-turnaround plan.
•Board decision on liquidity enhancement (summer 2025).
•Refinancing strategy for 2027 bullet maturities expected by year-end 2025.
Appendix
5. Appendix — Sources and Signals
•CHIA Hospital Financial Performance Databook; 2024-09-30
•Tufts Medicine Financial Report; 2024-06-30
•CHIA YTD Performance Databook; 2025-06-30
•Tufts Medical Center Financial Report; 2024-06-30
Data QA Notes
•CURRENT_RATING: “NR” – no agency rating conflicts.
•Interim CHIA YTD figures unaudited; margin calculations derive from CHIA tables, not issuer-filed statements.
•Foundation Analysis lacks explicit reserve-fund detail; assumes standard Massachusetts master-indenture construct.
Full Signal Details
(Verbatim text for Signals 22–33 and 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32 retained in the underlying signal map.)